Axar Patel Challenges Captaincy Bias: ‘English Does Not Define A Leader’
Axar Patel Challenges Captaincy Bias, firmly stating that fluency in English or a certain public personality has no bearing on a player’s ability to lead a team. In a candid interview, the India all-rounder dismantled the common, but flawed, narrative that a leader’s potential is tied to their language skills, a stereotype that is often used to judge non-English speaking cricketers in the modern era.
The India all-rounder, who recently led Delhi Capitals in the IPL after Rishabh Pant’s departure, insisted that a captain’s true job is purely operational: to understand the squad and find a way to get the best out of each player. His comments struck at the heart of a long-standing but rarely discussed bias within Indian cricket circles and public perception.
Axar Patel The Flawed Perception of Captaincy
Axar Patel highlighted the toxic public narrative surrounding captaincy selection, where competence is often confused with charisma or communication style. “People start saying ‘oh he is not a captaincy material, he doesn’t speak English. How will he talk? Yeh hai, voh hai [This and that]’,” Axar revealed. He countered this widely held captaincy perception, arguing that it is manufactured by the public and media, not based on cricketing reality. The core message is clear: the ability to lead is about strategic vision and player management, not eloquence.
The key duties of an IPL Captain, according to Axar, include identifying a player’s strength and weakness, and knowing “what I need to do to get work out of him.” He asserted that if the criteria remain “personality chahiye, acha English bolna chahiye,” then the sport is judging players on personal biases rather than cricketing merit. This emphasis on communication style creates an unnecessary language barrier for many talented leaders.
Leadership Mantra: Fun and Professionalism
Reflecting on his own stint leading the Delhi Capitals (DC), Axar opened up about his leadership philosophy, which focuses on maintaining a positive and highly professional team environment. His mantra is one of balance: “I want to keep the team environment friendly and lively, but no one should take things for granted.” He believes that a happy team is a high-performing team, provided the primary objective—winning the game—is never compromised.
“There’s a line – what needs to be done to win the game needs to be done first. Then we should have fun. It’s working at the moment. I believe that if you’re having fun, you do better,” he explained. This player-first approach, prioritizing clear intent and on-field results over public relations, is a refreshing counterpoint to the growing emphasis on media-friendly personalities in the league.
The Role of Social Media in Bias
The India all-rounder pointed out that the obsession with image and language is amplified by the current digital environment. Social media and traditional media coverage often play a significant role in fuelling this captaincy bias. “It’s all about what you see and what the media is showing. How active you are on social media. How you talk. People judge you on all that,” Axar noted. This constant scrutiny and the pervasive need for public opinion create a space where outward persona is given undue importance over fundamental leadership qualities.
Axar Patel’s powerful comments serve as a timely reminder that captaincy should be judged solely on results and team management, urging fans and critics alike to change their personal thinking and drop the language bias that has long overshadowed the assessment of India’s potential cricket leaders.
Responses