Test Cricket Calls As Ex-India Star Slams “Confused Team”
Test cricket chaos took centre stage after former India pacer Dodda Ganesh blasted the team management for a series of confusing decisions during the second Test against South Africa. The criticism—reflected directly in the title—became one of the biggest talking points of the match as fans questioned the team’s muddled approach. From unexpected batting reshuffles to inconsistent selections, India’s tactical uncertainties left supporters frustrated and analysts searching for answers.
Test Cricket Turmoil Deepens With India’s Confusing Batting Moves
The second Test in Guwahati exposed India’s erratic decision-making as the team experimented heavily with their batting lineup. In one of the series’ most talked-about moments, Washington Sundar—who batted admirably at number three in the previous match—was suddenly demoted to number eight. Such unpredictability shocked fans and highlighted broader issues within Test cricket planning, especially in high-pressure situations where clarity is crucial.
India vs South Africa Drama Peaks Over No. 3 Batting Position
The India vs South Africa series had already seen surprising choices at number three, with Karun Nair and Sai Sudharsan rotated before the assignment unexpectedly landed on Sundar in the first Test. In Guwahati, Sudharsan returned to the XI and was restored as the No. 3 batter. While the change appeared logical on paper, Sundar’s demotion created widespread confusion. Supporters felt the constant shuffling indicated a lack of strategic direction—something that has become a recurring pattern in India’s recent Test outings.
How Sudharsan’s Return Added To The Series Confusion
Sudharsan, who did not feature in the first Test despite being in the squad, was back for the second match only to see Sundar pushed down the order. The rotating roles left many questioning whether India had a clear plan for the crucial number-three slot. For a contest as significant as India vs South Africa, such indecision raised eyebrows across the cricketing community.
Dodda Ganesh Blasts Team India For “Confused” Test Cricket Approach
Former pacer Dodda Ganesh expressed his frustration openly, criticising the team’s unpredictable choices. Pointing to Sundar’s demotion, Ganesh wrote that he had “never seen a more confused Indian Test team ever.” His comments resonated with fans, who shared similar sentiments amid India’s shaky performances throughout the series. The criticism underlined how instability in decision-making often spills over into on-field results—particularly in Test cricket, where consistency is the backbone of success.
Why Ganesh’s Comments Struck a Chord With Fans
Ganesh emphasised that Sundar had played two quality innings at number three previously, making the shift to number eight surprising. Many felt the move lacked justification, especially considering Sundar’s ability to absorb pressure and steady the innings. In a high-stakes India vs South Africa Test, such changes suggested uncertainty rather than tactical flexibility.
India’s Batting Collapse Exposes Deeper Structural Issues
India’s first innings ended at 201 as the home side suffered yet another collapse. While the pitch demanded discipline and patience, Indian batters struggled to adapt. KL Rahul, Sai Sudharsan, Dhruv Jurel, Rishabh Pant, Ravindra Jadeja and Nitish Kumar Reddy all fell cheaply, further intensifying concerns about India’s planning and temperament in Test cricket conditions.
Washington Sundar And Kuldeep Yadav Lead Brief Revival
The only meaningful resistance came through a gritty 72-run eighth-wicket partnership between Washington Sundar and Kuldeep Yadav. Sundar battled hard for his 48 off 92 balls, showcasing once again why he deserved a higher spot in the order. Kuldeep, with a marathon 134-ball stay for 19 runs, demonstrated unwavering discipline. Their effort prevented an even worse collapse and highlighted what India lacked at the top: patience, resilience, and situational awareness in this India vs South Africa clash.
Marco Jansen Dismantles India With Devastating Spell
South African pacer Marco Jansen continued his sensational run, finishing with 6 for 48. His hostile lines, steep bounce and relentless accuracy dismantled India’s batting with precision. Partnering with Simon Harmer, who took three wickets, Jansen ensured India were restricted to a below-par total—amplifying the consequences of India’s earlier tactical errors in Test cricket strategy.
Indian Top Order Succumbs To Pace And Poor Shot Selection
Several batters looked unsettled from the start, committing errors that would be punished heavily in any India vs South Africa Test. Rahul’s loose shot, Sudharsan’s indecision, and Pant’s inability to settle added to India’s woes. Each dismissal deepened the feeling that confusion in selections had seeped into decision-making at the crease.
South Africa Strengthen Grip With Massive First-Innings Lead
South Africa’s commanding 489 in the first innings placed India on the back foot from the outset. After dismissing India for 201, the visitors returned to bat confidently, ending Day 3 at 26 for no loss. Openers Ryan Rickelton and Aiden Markram looked assured, extending the lead to 314 runs with two full days remaining—another reminder of how composure and consistency define success in high-level Test cricket.
India Struggle To Regroup As Series Slips Away
India’s bowlers found no early breakthroughs, allowing South Africa to tighten their control. As the match progressed, India’s lack of clarity—both in team selection and on-field execution—became increasingly apparent. The mounting pressure highlighted the impact of the earlier batting reshuffles and tactical unpredictability in this crucial India vs South Africa encounter.
India Must Rebuild Stability To Compete In Test Cricket
This series has underlined a harsh truth: India need coherent planning and stable roles to remain competitive in Test cricket. Selection consistency, tactical clarity and temperament must return to the forefront. For now, Dodda Ganesh’s remarks echo the broader sentiment—India appear confused, unsettled and far from their best in the longest format.
The Road Ahead Requires Clear Thinking And Strong Leadership
To regain momentum, India must rebuild their structure from the top down. That means defined roles, consistent team combinations and improved on-field execution. Only then can they restore confidence and reassert themselves in future India vs South Africa contests and other Test assignments.
Responses